A federal judge heard arguments Thursday on whether CNN, MS NOW and Politico can keep reporting from the White House while their lawsuit over a recent ban plays out. U.S. District Judge Timothy Kelly extended his earlier order that temporarily restored the outlets’ access and said he could decide by Tuesday whether to issue a longer injunction, according to the Associated Press and CBS News.
The fight began in September, when President Donald Trump said on Truth Social that reporters from the three outlets would be barred from the White House. The organizations sued later that month and won a temporary restraining order that let their journalists back in, CBS News and UPI reported. Even after that order, the administration at times limited access — including excluding CNN from certain broadcast pool duties and keeping some outlets out of the Oval Office and off Air Force One — according to AP and CBS News.
At Thursday’s hearing, lawyers for the outlets asked for a preliminary injunction to keep access in place as the case proceeds. Their attorney, Ted Boutrous, argued the ban was retaliatory and violated the First Amendment and due process, CBS News reported. The Justice Department countered that the president can set standards for professionalism and protect national security, and said the affected outlets fell short, CBS News and Courthouse News Service reported.
Kelly, a Trump appointee, pressed the government on why its courtroom arguments emphasized standards and security when the president’s public comments criticized negative coverage. He described parts of the government’s position as difficult to carry, the Associated Press reported. The judge also discussed prior D.C. Circuit decisions that require fair notice and clear rules before press credentials can be pulled, CBS News and Medill on the Hill reported.
The temporary order keeping access in place runs into early next week. AP said Kelly indicated he could rule by Tuesday on the request for a preliminary injunction. Mediaite noted that the judge signaled he was inclined to extend the block, and UPI described the extension as a short continuation of access using the reporters’ regular hard passes.
What happens between now and Tuesday matters for daily coverage. AP reported that CNN’s turn in the television pool has resumed on a limited basis, though restrictions have been uneven. Boutrous told the court the White House ban reaches multiple credentialed journalists across the three organizations, CBS News reported.
Why it matters
Press access sets the ground rules for how the public learns what the White House is doing. If a president can bar major outlets over coverage he dislikes, future presidents of either party could try the same. The judge’s decision could help define how far a White House can go — and how firmly the First Amendment protects on-the-job reporting for national audiences.