Federal judge rejects Justice Department push to segregate thousands of California ballots

Federal judge rejects Justice Department push to segregate thousands of California ballots

A federal judge in Los Angeles denied the Justice Department’s request to have California set aside thousands of ballots, keeping the state’s normal counting process in place days before the midterms. U.S. District Judge David O. Carter refused to issue an emergency order to segregate ballots tied to a group of voters flagged by federal officials as potential noncitizens, according to the Washington Post and the Associated Press.

Carter said the request ran against long‑standing constitutional limits on federal involvement in state‑run elections and warned that changing procedures now could disrupt voting already underway. In his order, he said separating ballots at this stage could cause major disruption and risk discounting eligible votes, AP reported. The Washington Post noted that Carter also said the move could violate federal voting laws.

The ruling came after a hearing earlier in the week and followed a related setback for the government. Earlier, a divided three‑judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit declined an emergency bid to force California to isolate the ballots and sent the matter back to Carter; some judges indicated they would have rejected the government’s request on the merits, the Los Angeles Times and Washington Post reported.

The Justice Department sued the state, Secretary of State Shirley Weber, and Los Angeles County Registrar Dean Logan recently, arguing that California had not acted on a federal list identifying thousands of people the department says may not be U.S. citizens. Prosecutors asked the court to require counties to sequester any ballots from those voters while their status is checked. First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bill Essayli said the government would appeal Carter’s ruling and argued that segregating the ballots could prevent dilution by ineligible votes, the Post, AP and Los Angeles Times reported.

State and county officials have pushed back on the federal data, calling it unreliable and incomplete. The Post reported that election officials say the list includes people who are not registered to vote and people who appear to be U.S. citizens. The Times said Los Angeles County’s spot‑check of a subset found many appeared to have been born in the United States. It’s also unclear how many of the listed individuals were ever mailed ballots or have returned them, according to the Post.

Timing and mechanics mattered to the court. By that point, a large number of ballots had already been processed in California, meaning envelopes were verified and separated from the votes inside — a step that would make retroactive segregation difficult, AP reported. Carter also criticized federal letters warning county officials of potential criminal penalties if they didn’t comply, saying such threats should stop, the Times reported.

California mails ballots to all registered voters, and counting continues as they arrive. The Justice Department has pursued a similar ballot‑segregation effort in Washington state, AP reported. Carter’s decision leaves California’s procedures intact while any appeal plays out.

Why it matters

This ruling keeps California’s vote counting on its regular track days before the midterms, reducing the odds of last‑minute confusion for election workers and voters. It also highlights that states, not the federal executive branch, run elections. For busy voters, the bottom line is simple: California is keeping processing ballots as usual while the legal fight continues, and any changes could face a high bar in court.

October 29, 2026 (0)