An appeals court recently declined to block California from counting a set of disputed ballots that the Justice Department says may belong to noncitizen voters, leaving the tally to continue for now while the underlying lawsuit returns to a lower court. A divided Ninth Circuit panel dismissed the administration’s emergency appeal and sent the dispute back to a federal judge for a scheduled hearing later this week. According to the Associated Press and CBS News, the ruling meant no immediate change to California’s vote-counting process. ([apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/ed14390afb8af8fde1c2d0f6a90a0761))
The panel said it lacked jurisdiction because the district court had not yet ruled on the government’s request to set aside the ballots, and judges faulted the late timing of the appeal. One judge warned that changing the rules midstream could create serious disruption, while another questioned whether the executive branch has constitutional authority to require states to segregate certain ballots. News reports said the majority also described the claimed emergency as partly self-created by the government’s delay. ([apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/ed14390afb8af8fde1c2d0f6a90a0761))
Judge Patrick Bumatay dissented, arguing the federal government has a strong interest in ensuring only eligible voters participate in federal elections and that noncitizen voting is prohibited under federal and state law. His opinion would have allowed the government to seek faster relief. Those points were summarized by the Associated Press and CBS News. ([apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/ed14390afb8af8fde1c2d0f6a90a0761))
The dispute stems from a Justice Department lawsuit filed recently that asked a federal judge to require California to set aside ballots from people on a federal list the department says are likely noncitizens and to verify their citizenship before counting those votes. The department sent short-deadline demand letters to state and county officials before going to court; a district judge scheduled a hearing later this week, and the government then sought an early appeal to the Ninth Circuit. CBS News and AP outlined that sequence; the department’s request is reflected in DOJ filings and press materials. ([cbsnews.com](https://www.cbsnews.com/news/appeals-court-dismisses-doj-trump-california-ballots/?intcid=CNR-02-0623))
California officials have challenged the reliability of the federal list. In a sample review, Los Angeles County said many entries were canceled or inactive registrations, some had never voted, and some listed U.S. birthplaces—raising questions about the data behind the federal claims, CBS News reported. State Attorney General Rob Bonta called the appellate decision an early legal win for California and urged voters to keep participating as usual, according to his office. ([cbsnews.com](https://www.cbsnews.com/news/appeals-court-dismisses-doj-trump-california-ballots/?intcid=CNR-02-0623))
News outlets in California said the immediate effect is that counting continues while the case moves ahead in U.S. District Court. FOX 11 Los Angeles reported the Ninth Circuit’s dismissal of the emergency appeal. The Washington Post’s write-up echoed AP’s account of the ruling and the scheduled district hearing. ([foxla.com](https://www.foxla.com/news/ninth-circuit-dismisses-trump-administrations-emergency-appeal-over-20000-california-mail-ballots.amp))
Why it matters
This fight is about who runs elections—states or the federal executive branch—and how officials handle ballots flagged as questionable without wrongly tossing votes from eligible citizens. The court’s decision keeps counting on track while questions about the government’s authority and the accuracy of its list get a fuller airing. With Election Day approaching, the ruling could help avoid abrupt changes that might confuse voters and strain local election offices. ([cbsnews.com](https://www.cbsnews.com/news/appeals-court-dismisses-doj-trump-california-ballots/?intcid=CNR-02-0623))