A federal judge in Alaska recently threw out the Justice Department’s attempt to block certification of the state’s Senate race if Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan were to lose, narrowing the department’s late effort to change how the vote would be handled. U.S. District Judge Sharon L. Gleason said the department hadn’t shown a workable way to separate and review certain ballots without compromising voter privacy. She also concluded the government hadn’t met the legal test to bring the case at this stage, CBS News and The Washington Post reported.
The lawsuit, filed in late October, argued Alaska should set aside ballots cast for another candidate on the ballot who shares Sullivan’s name — Daniel J. Sullivan — and delay certification while investigators probed whether voter confusion altered the outcome. In her order, Gleason said there was no workable way to do that while keeping ballot secrecy intact, according to CBS News. Alaska Public Media noted the state had taken steps to distinguish the two men on the ballot.
The Justice Department appealed the decision, saying the judge dismissed the case on procedural grounds but not on the underlying concerns about voter confusion, CBS News and KTUU reported. Axios added that the department’s request would have paused certification only if the incumbent narrowly lost and votes for the other Dan Sullivan appeared decisive.
Ranked-choice voting is in effect for Alaska’s U.S. Senate contest. Four candidates are on the ballot, and if no one wins a majority on the first count, the last-place finisher is eliminated and those voters’ next choices are redistributed until someone crosses 50%, The Washington Post explained. Earlier this year, the Alaska Supreme Court allowed Daniel J. Sullivan to remain on the ballot after a challenge, Alaska Public Media reported.
The race itself is unusually tight, with national implications. The Associated Press and Roll Call describe it as one of a handful that could determine control of the Senate. The Democratic candidate, former congresswoman Mary Peltola, has denied allegations — highlighted in recent reporting and cited by the Justice Department — that her team or allies recruited a namesake candidate to confuse voters. No one has been charged, but federal authorities are investigating, according to the AP and CBS News.
Gleason’s ruling also stressed the risks of changing election procedures days before voting finishes. The AP reported that she pointed to constitutional limits on federal interference in how states run elections and echoed a Supreme Court principle cautioning courts against late adjustments that could disrupt voting.
For now, Alaska’s election is proceeding under existing rules. State officials opposed the federal suit, calling an after-the-fact inquiry into voter intent unworkable because ballots are secret and comingled, Alaska Public Media reported. The Ninth Circuit could weigh the Justice Department’s appeal, but unless that court reverses quickly, ballots may be counted and the result certified on Alaska’s standard timeline.
Why it matters
The decision keeps Alaska’s voting process stable heading into Election Day and reduces the chance of a prolonged fight over how to count ballots. In a race that could tip Senate control, clear rules and timely certification help voters trust the outcome. And for busy Alaskans, it means fewer last-minute changes at the polls and a result that arrives closer to schedule.