A federal appeals court recently rejected the Justice Department’s emergency bid to have California set aside ballots flagged by federal authorities as possibly cast by noncitizens. Hours later, a separate federal judge in San Francisco temporarily barred the government from threatening or pressuring election workers over how they handle those ballots, with Election Day approaching. CBS News and the Associated Press reported the back-to-back rulings, which leave California’s vote-counting rules in place for now.
The U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against the administration’s request tied to a federal list of California voters that the Justice Department says may not be citizens. News reports said the majority questioned the reliability of the federal list and the wisdom of changing ballot-handling procedures in the middle of an election, noting the risk of disenfranchising eligible voters. One judge dissented. Reports said the appeals court’s decision followed earlier defeats for the administration in the same dispute.
In a related case, reporting said a U.S. district judge in San Francisco issued a temporary restraining order prohibiting the Justice and Homeland Security departments from instructing state and local officials to segregate ballots, remove voters from the rolls, or threaten prosecutions based solely on federal allegations of ineligibility. The order, brought by labor unions and civil-rights groups, runs into mid-November and requires the government to notify jurisdictions that received its earlier warning letters. ABC News noted the order bars threatening or coercing election workers over ballots from registered voters alleged to be ineligible.
Those steps followed a separate ruling in Los Angeles, where a U.S. district judge rejected the administration’s bid to force California to sequester ballots linked to the flagged voter list, saying such a change would be disruptive with voting underway. Reporting said that judge also warned federal officials against threatening state and county employees during the dispute.
Even as courts pushed back, reporting from KQED and the Los Angeles Times said federal prosecutors issued grand jury subpoenas to local election offices, seeking records and testimony related to the government’s allegations. A county official described the approach as confrontational.
California officials and outside experts have raised doubts about the accuracy of the federal list. One report said county staff who reviewed a sample found many registrations were canceled or inactive — meaning those individuals would not have been mailed ballots. The Washington Post noted federal authorities have made similar requests in other states, and that the outcome of the California litigation could shape how far the federal government may go in using such lists to intervene in state-run elections.
The Justice Department has said it is enforcing laws that prohibit noncitizens from voting and has argued that counting any ballots it deems ineligible could affect the weight of other citizens’ votes, as Axios and the Associated Press reported. California officials counter that the state already has processes to detect and pursue unlawful voting without sweeping mid-election changes that could block lawful ballots.
Why it matters
This affects whether legally cast votes in California are counted without last-minute changes and whether the people running polling places can do their jobs without fear of prosecution. It also signals how judges across the country may treat federal efforts to alter election procedures close to Election Day. For voters, the rulings aim to keep the rules stable and protect election workers as they process a large volume of ballots in the days before the election.