The Supreme Court declined to revive plea agreements for three men accused of plotting the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, including Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. The decision leaves in place the Pentagon’s move to scrap the deals and keeps the long‑running Guantánamo prosecutions on course for potential death‑penalty trials, according to CBS News and the Associated Press.
The justices issued a brief, unsigned order that offered no explanation, a common outcome when the court declines to hear a case. One justice did not participate, CBS News reported. Axios noted the decision appeared on the court’s routine order list.
Under the scuttled arrangements, Mohammed and two co‑defendants—Mustafa al Hawsawi and Walid bin ’Atash—would have pleaded guilty and received life sentences, removing the death penalty from consideration, AP reported. Reports said the plea agreements had been approved by the Pentagon official who oversees the military commissions, but the defense secretary later withdrew them; AP reported the defense secretary said such decisions should rest with that office.
The legal back‑and‑forth that followed stretched across multiple courts. Reports say some judges concluded the withdrawal was unlawful while appellate panels later reached the opposite conclusion, according to CBS News and AP.
Bloomberg Law reported that the Supreme Court action leaves the government’s withdrawal of the plea deals in place. The Washington Examiner similarly described the outcome as backing the Pentagon’s decision to revoke the agreements.
With the plea path closed, the cases continue toward long‑anticipated capital trials before a military commission at Guantánamo Bay. Axios and CBS News reported that a judge has set a tentative trial date several years out, contingent on the parties meeting numerous pretrial milestones. USA Today likewise framed the court’s move as keeping the prosecution on the trial track rather than resolving the matter through negotiated pleas.
The prosecutions have been slowed for years by disputes over evidence, including whether statements obtained during so‑called enhanced interrogation techniques can be used at trial, CBS News reported. AP noted that families of Sept. 11 victims were divided over the proposed pleas—some favored a trial, while others saw plea agreements as a way to bring the decades‑long case to an end sooner.
Why it matters
The court’s decision means the government could again seek the death penalty against the accused 9/11 plotters, and the sprawling Guantánamo cases could keep moving toward trials rather than negotiated pleas. For families and the public, that could bring fuller airing of evidence but also more years of pretrial litigation and costs. It also underscores how national‑security cases can stretch across administrations and courts before reaching any final resolution.